UHH THAT'S KINDA TUFF I LOVE ASHLEY BUT I'M GONNA HAVE TO SAY IT LOOKS BETTER ON BRENDA I THINK IT'S A LITTLE TOO LIGHT FOT ASHLEY AND MAKES HER LOOK A LITTLE PALE!!

It looks better on Ashley!!! She is wearing it baggy so it looks casual. But I like Brenda better as a person.

I don't think it looks that good on either one. They both should find another dress.

I don't think it looks that good on either one. They both should find another dress.

I meant Brenda Song

Ashley's hair deoesnt go well with the yellow, I think brendo looks great with the oragne clutch!

hah ok so i spelled Brenda wrong. lol

Put that in J-14!! omg with a quote!! do itttt

thay both look relly good but brenda look's relly
pretty in it.
Ashely does 2 but brenda look's better.

I think Ashley Tisdale looks better!, but I think Brenda Song is a better actress!! Above all Selena Gomez is my favorite!! She totally rocks! I love how she's a star and a real (down-to-earth) person at the same time! She makes mistakes and messes up like every other human person. She also has family secerets and troubles. I think ur awesome Selena!!!!!

Anna: Brenda! Its not Ash that I dont like, the thing is that purple is my fave color so it really isnt Ashley.

Katie: Ashley wore it better. I think that yellow is a good color for her. And since when do the outfits that people wear matter? Oh yeah, unfortunently they always did.

Cara: Brenda

Leah: Brenda

Becca: Ashley looks better and I agree with Katie.

Linda: I agree with Rebbecca and Katie.

Molly: Might as well copy and paste Katies comment on here! But Brenda looks pretty as well. Brenda IS prettier, but Ashes dress is awesome. But they are both cool people and what they wear doesnt matter to me.

i think that Brenda wore it better because of her length. on Ashley it looks more like a shirt and the yellow doesnt go as well with her complexion. but i still think that it looks good on the both of them.

I think Brenda Song cause her shoes
match with her dress and stuff

Plus...the dress looks like it's for
like Asian people to where ans Ashley
is not Asian

Ashley's dress is too baggy, and the yellow does not compliment her hair at all. It looks better on Brenda, the red shoes and orange bag really make it pop!

well, i like ashley better than brenda, but brenda wears it better. honestly, it's still an ugly dress. sorry :(

Brenda deffinately wore it better! Her orange clutch and shoes matche the orange in the design on the dress. Also, her hair goes better with the dark color of the dress. On the other hand, that dress does NOT look good on Ashley. Her hair color blends in too much, and her shoes are bland, when there are so many colors in the dress. I also don't like how the white with bright colors looks with Ashley's skin, because the white and skin all blends. I like Brenda's dress with her skin because it pops and there is contrast. Good choice, Brenda!!!

I THIN ASHLEY TISDALE WORE IT BETTER.BRENDA DRESS IS TO GIRLYISH

it luk so much betta on brenda den ashley... i luv it on ha

it look much better on breanda...the colors of her dress match her skin tones better that ashley even though i loved them both !!

i think it looks alot better on ashley im not hatin on brenda but it dnt look good on her but yea keep on rockin ashley we luv you

Sorry Ashley. But I think the outfit hugs Brenda's features more on this one!

um i have to say it does look way better on brenda. her hair and practically flawless asian skin compliments the color of the dress. plus, her clutch and pumps jazz it up while giving it an extra punch.
sorry ash, but your friend and ex-co star beat u on this one.

brenda, of course. The same thing looks nice on ashley but the color clashes with her skin tone. the dark midnight/ navy blue suites brenda's hair and skin.

I think Ashley wore it better! The yellow might be a little pale but, I think it still looks AWESOME!

I think that ASHLEY wore it better!

And who ever said that blonde people shouldind wear yellow its shit !

I like Brenda's style better. Ash's outfit washes her out.

As much as I luv u Ashley, I have 2 say that Brenda looks better! Ashley looks so... yellow in the picture. From the dress, 2 the hair, and this may sound racist but even 2 her skin she looks too yellow-y. (I'm so sorry Ashley Tisdale! I'll never say anything like that again. I'm super super super sorry!) As 4 Brenda, she looks classic and sophisticated. Just the way I like it!

ASHLEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!BRENDA'S DRESS IS TO GIRLY AS ROSA SAYS

BRENDA SONG!! I do love Ashley Tisdale though.

Brenda Song ,Brenda Song ,Brenda Song ,Brenda Song ,Brenda Song

I think that Brenda looks better. Blondes shouldn't wear yellow. And yellow doesn't look good on lighter skin. It washes Ashley out a little. Brenda's orange clutch is a perfect addition

it looks wayy better on brenda than on ashley. brenda made it pop because she used a cute clutch and rockin shoes.ashley looked kind of washed out with such a bright color!!! sorry ashley!brenda won!!oh yeah!! ashley your shoes are UGLY!!!!

i'd have to say brenda but thats only cuz of the color of the dress i think if brenda tightend up her body a little more and lost some weight she might look better! ashley's body looks MUCH better in the dress than brenda but the color is not right and theirs too much going on in the pattern

Brenda, because the colors go better with her skin and it fits her figure, on Ashley it looks to short and makes er look pale!!!!

hard....... Not! Ash, totally!

I think that Brenda looks better with the dress. The dress looks too short on Ashley and the color doesn't match her at all.

BRENDA SONG SOOO TOTALLY WORE IT BETTER!!SHE LOOKS LIKE OH SO HOTT!!SHE IS SOOO WORKING THAT DRESS N SHOES!!

ashely looks sooooooooooo better

I think it looks way better on brenda. Yellow washs ashley out. And purple looks really good on brenda.

i dont really like the dress but brenda!

It's pretty hard, but I think that Brenda wore it better. She just ties the outfit together better. Ashley needed some more accessories, and the dress is just to light, and doesnt help with her skin complection and hair color. It looks sort of dull.

i love both

Brenda looks fabulous but Ashley is off the charts. Her bright yellow dress with beautiful colored flowers really makes her stand out. She just looks FABULOUS! Brenda is beautiful too.

Brenda looks so much better because the yellow dress on Ashley looks bad.Brenda's dress looks perfect on her

I love Ashley, but I think Brenda wore it better. Either way, I really don't like the dress they wore.

I really think Brenda wore it better
the color really looks great on her.

i like ashley and all but brenda looks better.she has better accesories and hair that time.but ashleys hair dosent match either.so yea brenda looks better.;)

Like fan number 2 said it is tuff because I like Ashley Tidale and I have to say Brenda song. Yellow is a little to bright and the color on Brenda is a very nice color on her.

i think brenda song wore it best the color of ashley's is just 2 light for her hair and skin tone

i think brenda song wore it best the color of Ashley's is just 2 light for her hair and skin tone

i think brenda song wore it best the color of Ashley's is just 2 light for her hair and skin tone

i think brenda song wore it best the color of Ashley's is just 2 light for her hair and skin tone

i think brenda song wore it best the color of Ashley's is just 2 light for her hair and skin tone

I agree w ashley brenda looks cute in the outfit bt ashley looked nt as gd if it was in red then yea she would of totally rocked it

The dress on Ashley is baggy and unflattering, and along with her stringy hair and washed-out face, it makes her look sloppy. It definitely looks better on Brenda.

i ment dress. and i dont just not like the dress i think Brenda should of have the acssisories the same color and Ashley im sorry:-( your shoes are, let me put it this way,they are UGLY!!!! :(

i think i like it on Brenda better,but if it was a little longer on Ashley i would have picked Ashley.

BRENDa DEFINITELY WORE IT BETTER
BRENDA BRENDA BRENDA BRENDA

BRENDA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BRENDa DEFINITELY WORE IT BETTER
BRENDA BRENDA BRENDA BRENDA

BRENDA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Thats hard.......................... Not! Ash totaly!

i think it looks OK on both of them, but if i had to choose, i would choose defieneitly Brenda.

brenda songg. its looks to short on ashleyy.

I THINK BRENDA DID SRY ASH. I LUV U 2

hmmm...That's a tuff one.
They both look lovely.
I'm going to say Ashley wore it a little better!
:)

I think Brenda rocked it better! I love being bold and wearing bright colors as much as the next gurl but Ashley's just screams "Sunshine" and that is so kindergarten.

I think Brenda looks georgous in this dress. The dress makes her skin color more noticeable. Ashely's dress looks nice but it looks too much yellow on her.

I think Brenda looks georgous in this dress. The dress makes her skin color more noticeable. Ashely's dress looks nice but it looks too much yellow on her.

I think Brenda looks georgous in this dress. The dress makes her skin color more noticeable. Ashely's dress looks nice but it looks too much yellow on her.

I think Brenda Song looks way better in it, because her dark hair and the blue of the dress just go together perfectly.

I think Brenda sing looks better wearing the outfit because shes really pretty and her body and her hair is just the right look for it thats what I say. .

Brenda's color "pops" more and the red heels add an awesome touch; Ashley's blond hair sort of blends in.

Brenda wore it better.....but i like the dress yellow like on Ashley

Brenda wore it better. Ashley's yellow dress didn't go good with her blonde hair and light skin. Brenda's red shoes and orange purse looked good with the dress.

OMG SO MUCH BETTER ON ASHLY NO AFENCE BRENDA I STILL LOVE YOURS BUT ASHLY`S BETTER

Brenda wore the dress better.on ashley,it looks too short.And the color really makes a difference too.

brenda,but i love ashley!

wellll..... i love ashley shes goergus sweet fun sassy i love the color yellow on her and she always keeps her makeup natural but her hair needs some fixing so i say brenda

Sorry Ashley but Brenda pulls this off way better. Brenda looks so chic and beautiful. With her red shoes and orange bag, she can go anywhere. Plus I think Brenda looks more confident, Ashley looks a little sick.
I ♥ you, Brenda

brenda wore it way better luv the shoes and bag!plus brenda is asain and that is a asian dress.

luv victoria aka tory

BRENDA SONG

i love both of the dresses.
I like brenda's bcuz of her orange heels
Ashley's hair has an edgy twist with her yellow dress

i think that ashley is workin it and brenda is kind of ugly with her dress.

i like both people, but i think brenda wore it better, because the dress is to light nd ashley looks kind of pail nd plain.

BRENDA SONG!
SIMPLE AS THAT!!!!

I'm gonna go with Brenda on this one.

DEFINELY BRENDA SONG BECAUSE THE SHOES REALLY GO W/ HER AND ASHLEY SINCE SHE IS WHITE IT DOSEN'T REALLY FIT HER. :)

to be completely honest i think you guys are being a little judgemental saying eww thats so ugly. i think it looks good on both stars

Brenda wore it best this time.The color looks better on Brenda and that dress is wayyyyyyyyyyyyy too bright for Ashley's skin tone.

LOVE YA!

Brenda wore it best and Ashley's dress is way too bright for her.

LOVE YA!

Brenda all the way!!!!!

Ya girl i agree Ashleys face is to light and brendas goes wuth the flow

i luv ashley but brenda wins this one

i like it on Ashley more! i like the yellow better! the blue is boring

i think it looks better on brenda. ashley's is a little too light on her. it kind of makes her look pale. but brenda's suits her better.

i think ashley wear it better but you all rock

omg. thtz a tuffy. cant answer this 1.

omg. thtz a tuffy. cant answer this 1.

personally,, i like ashley's betta cuz she look fantabulus in yellow -.-"

I THINK BRENDA LOOKS BETTER IN IT LOVE THEM BOTH BUT BRENDA WORE IT BETTER

They both look cute but Brenda wore it better! The color of the dress is much more flattering.

Brenda. The fit is better, and she pairs it with some great accessories.

I'm not crazy about the dress but i think Ashley wore it better

It looks awesome on both girls but i have to say Brenda. Sorrry ash.

black is just so depressing! light looks best . . . so ashley gets my vote!

Like I said b4 with miley and selena....they both rock the outfit.

i agree with megan!!!! although i also dont know but is just looks soo much better on brenda!!

I think brenda looks a lot better in the dress. But i love ashley tisdale!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

well let me see uh... ashley ASHLEY ASHLEY ASHLEY!!!! jesus christ how many times do i hve to say it

well let me see uh... ashley ASHLEY ASHLEY ASHLEY!!!! jesus christ how many times do i hve to say it

well let me see uh... ashley ASHLEY ASHLEY ASHLEY!!!! jesus christ how many times do i hve to say it

well let me see uh... ashley ASHLEY ASHLEY ASHLEY!!!! jesus christ how many times do i hve to say it

i think brenda song wore it better because of her acceriories and stuuf even though i like ashley more than brenda

I'm going to have to say that Ashley totally wore it better?

i think brenda looksz better in it...
ashley looksz tooh skinny in that dress..

Deff. Brenda. Ashleys dress blends into her skin & hair to much. Brenda looks fab in the fadded purple!

Ashley's shoes don't really go together with her outfit but Brenda's fit perfectly and she has a cute hand purse to make her outfit pop .

Ashley's shoes don't really go together with her outfit but Brenda's fit perfectly and she has a cute hand purse to make her outfit pop .

Ashley's shoes don't really go together with her outfit but Brenda's fit perfectly and she has a cute hand purse to make her outfit pop .

Brenda Song wore it so much better than ashley!

ASHLEY WORE IT SOOO MUCH BETTER BRENDA WHOS BRENDA HA HA HAHA HA ;9

Brenda Song definitely wore this outfit best.
The dark color on Brenda's really brings out the tone in her skin, therefore as Ashley Tisdale's light colored ensemble wasn't quite the same. Ashley's was too light, making her look completely pale in this. A darker color for Ashley would have brought out her beautiful tan.
They are both great, but Brenda definitely pulled it off better this time.
Brenda's red cutsey shoes also bring out and go along the colors in this dress, as Ashley's tan shoes don't really go along with the bright coloring. :)

brenda def!! the colors of the clutch and shoes make the colors on the dress stand out!! ashley just looks plain weird.

brenda for sure!! >..

i think it looks better on Brenda because of her dair skin and hair brings out the colors in the dress, i also think that the dress looks better on shorter people. ashley is too tall for the dress!

brenda wore it totally better. she's prettier, too.

I love them both buuuttt.....
Brenda!
Sorry Ash, but i think Brenda pulled this outfit off better...i like the colors better and yellow on Ash, well she shouldn't do it again...sorry but...
Brenda!

i think that brenda song because ashley like has blone hair and it blends in to much...and brenda hair is darker and that she is were dark purpleee

but i LOVE them both XD

OMG wake up ashley is fakee! jelouse of life and vaneessa hudgens she trys 2 hard it looks better on brenda!!!!!!!!!!!!! brings out her hair and dark skin

Both look terrible... sorry girls

Brenda looks good and her pose is cute but on the other hand,Ashley's legs are far apart and it looks like she's trying to get you to look under. Brenda looks fab! U go girl!

I love Ashley but I have to ammit it looks loose on Ashley but it really fits Brenda

I would have to say Ashley wore it better.