Who Wore It Better -- J-14.COM Edition!

blakeamerica.jpg

Both Leighton Meester & America Ferrera wore this on each of their TV shows, Gossip Girl and Ugly Betty, but who do you think wore it better? Let us know!

Photo: Startraks

184 Comments

First comment!!!

Of course Leighton does. But thats not fair to do because Ugly Betty is always gonna have someting funky on. Its her character's style, not her style.

America is a lot prettier being America and not Betty!!!

Leighton is very pretty too.

*LeIgHtOn AnD aMeRiCa RoCk My SoX*

MuCh LoVe
XoXo,
Piper

A j-14 reader on February 5, 2009 5:56 PM

I think leigthon is better.It flash her out.But America wear to much.

I think Leighton wore it better. But that's only because America is dressed for her charcter Betty on the show Ugly Betty so her clothes are supposed to look well...ugly!

isn't this too obvious, duh America! just kidding, that was sorts lame, but oh well. I think leighton wore it better, and she's really pretty in it there.

I think Leighton wore it better

it was so oo leighton

leighton wore it better
leighton wore it better
leighton wore it better
leighton wore it better
leighton wore it better


I know this is weird, but i'm gonna say America!
+ her show's WWWWWAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYYYY better!

Leighton wore it better but no wonder that ugly betty wore it funky thats her character

america ferrera duh!!!!!!!!!!

Of course Leighton wore it better.. But America was in costume for Ugly Betty. But Leighton could wear anything and everything better than America ;)

Leighton wore it better. The show is call UGLY betty.

leighton duh!!!

Of course, Leighton! But isn't that a dress from Stardoll!

Surely u cant be ME.darrr on February 6, 2009 4:42 AM

HAHAHA. they both look like OLD granny's.
oh wait that would be an insult to old granny's!
i really don't like it!!
SORRY

Um.. well i like them both there very fashinabal!
so stop making fun of them!!
GOSH!
Leightons is better though

SkipperGirl on February 6, 2009 5:23 AM

Leighton. DUH! LOL. Leighton keeps it plain.

leighton! duh!

Jade Middleditch on February 6, 2009 8:12 AM

Miss. MILEY CYRUS wore it better it looks ugly on leighton!! It look's prettier on Miley and the pink belt goes the other one makes her look like a granny!

Leighton wore it much better, but on America it looks great too.!

leighton

of coursee leighton did!
i mean i love america fererra
but leighton looks ahhmazingg and that outfit is hot
and besides that outfit on america is disgustingg!

UH DUh thats why its called UGLY BETTY !.
lolss.

Yeah leighton totally wore it better!

leighton, totally

OMG it is Legiton who is better floral with a pink? no!!

Well of course leighton wore it better. That's not fair cuz Betty's always gonna wear something ugly. She could probably rock it if she was America, but hey, what can you do.
Butta yea on the other hand, Leighton really looks pretty in it the way she put it together :)

....and that's not even the same dress!!!!!(i just realized)
....it's just the same print!!!!!

....well actually it might be cuz i just noticed Leighton's collar!!!.......but.....umm......they're still different colors!!!

leighton wore it betterr!!!!!

Leighton messer pulls it off as usual. But America is in costume for "ugly" Betty. not "beautiful" Betty so what did you excpect?

Leighton..obviously

Leighton

Leighton wore it better!

leighton wore it better

leighton did......
she made it look
girly and simple
while America
had too much
goin on=]

Leighton did, duh! But its not fair to compare. Its Betty's style, not America's....

Leighton Meester...

Leighton wore it better def. America over did it with that jacket thing. It also looks like the dress it too tight on her... ouch!

America is gorgeous, but her character ugly betty looked pretty bad in that outfit, not he shape,but the tights. Leighton wore it better

America looks horrible!

leighton meester wore it better. whats with america's belt, socks, and sweater?

Both are super ugly and i would never wear either but leighton's dress is way better than america ferras ugly betty look!

Leighton!!!!!

Leighton does, of couse!!!!

Definetly Leighton Meester, but that is America playing in Ugly Betty so of cource it looks a little more out of style!

Of course leighton looks better, but what do you expect? i mean, its Ugly Betty.

Leighton

OMG!America ferrera is so not looking good!

Leighton SO WON THIS! oF COURSE ITS UGLY BETTEY WHAT DID YOU EXPECT OF HER?

Well I think Leighton Meester wore it better!!!!

Leighton wins, BY FAR, but here are things I don't like about either of their styles:
Leighton wears it with bare legs!
Betty/America wears it with awful accesories!

ok, i think we all know who looks better, but america is in ugly bettey mode, so this one shouldnt count.

Look, I'm gonna give you my honest opinion. Neither because of the fact that:
1) They are both wearing it on the show.... they make it sound like they are wearing it out in public.
2) Leighton is wearing floral....so out! And America is wearing the ugliest thing I have ever seen, only cuz she has too.
3) you can't exactly say who wore it better cuz there not the same thing. If your gonna ask me that make sure I'm looking at the same outfit on both. That is not the same.
So to tell you the truth, neither of then look good in that out fit. Sorry!

geez..y is this even contest??! leighton wore it wayyyy better (gossip girl--fashionable, ugly betty--well..ugly...)

i think that leighton wore it MUCH better!

Ohh, Leighton all the way. Her flora dress makes her look pettie. But America's outfit...WOW! And not in a good way, or okay way, or even bad way. Shouldn't Betty have SOME style by now?

Omg leighton all the way! Like america, no offence, what up wit the stockings??? And the belt?
-Sarah xoxo
LOVE YOU J14!!!

I think Leighton Americas is really ugly

Leighton wore it wayyyy BETTER! than America.But I love the show Ugly Betty.

Leighton Wore It so Much Better Then Ugly Betty

I love America but im gonna have to say leighton wore it better!!! It brings out her inner beauty and just to let go and be yourself!!!

I think my choice will have 2 be........

AMERICA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Um..., people who like "MILEY CRYUS", F.Y.I., its not her, its Leighton Meester. So STOP SAYING, "I LIKE MILEY!"

Leighton wore the dress better than America because there's the perfect amount of accessories and America is overloaded with accessories.

I think miley wore it better stries dont go good with dress's and mileys head baned so CUITE!!!!!!!!!!!!

odio que te quiero on February 8, 2009 8:32 AM

no duhh Leighton did, but that really unfair cuz the show is called UGLY betty and the clothes she wears there are well UGLY (if u havent noticed)

Leighton Meester all the way!

Leighton wore this MUCH better, which isn't fair because America was on set for UGLY Betty.

Leighton wore it way better than America.

leighton totally wore it better

Leighton roed dat dress!!!! =)

Abby N.R.C.M.P. on February 8, 2009 3:10 PM

leighton wore it better,of course!

I think Leighton wore this better. (:

i say leighton wore it better but america looks wicked with da tights!

Leighton wore it better.
Only because America added too much.
:)

Well Leighton wore it better!
America added to much and it looks better in the color Leghtion wore it in! :)

I think America wore it better! she has more funk to it! :D

haha i think Leighton Meester wore it better! it looks actually nice on her ;)

they all look good in tha dress
but Leighton wore it simple and without all these assesories but decorate it wi/ cute headband and bracelet
oxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxo

Deanna Torrisi on February 8, 2009 6:20 PM

Um.... LEIGHTON MEESTER America ferrera is completely clashing and that dress makes her look REALLY fat.

Leighton definitely wore it better. Sorry America!! :)

Leighton

Well Of Course Blair Wore It Better . She's Like A Fashion Icon !! She Dresses Like A Goddess ^^ . Alright I'd Wish I Could Be Her .. She's Sooo Pretty ! It Has Nothing To Do With The Subject ! Lol

Maddie x o x o on February 9, 2009 10:42 AM

Leighton hands down!! She looks gorgeous!!

leightonn...


Leighton!

Leighton!

Leighton!

Leighton wore it better.

I love how America wore it though. Totally unique. I never would have thought of wearing it like that.

But, anyway, Leighton DID wear it better. It really looks fantastic on her.

Leighton. Idk who she is, but she pulled it off better than America.

Leighton Meester has it!
DING! DING! DING!
America, hun, sorry you have too many patterns!

obviously Leighton Meester. But America was in a costume. Leighton looked like a normal person. Not that Betty isnt normal. lol

obviously Leighton Meester. But America was in a costume. Leighton looked like a normal person. Not that Betty isnt normal. lol

obviously Leighton Meester. But America was in a costume. Leighton looked like a normal person. Not that Betty isnt normal. lol

Duhhh...Leighton Meeseter totally looks sooooo much better than America Ferrara but that isnt really fair to her cuz she was in her ugly betty costume...

leighton wore it much better, much much better

leighto wore it better much much better

I'm a sucker for clashing patterns so I have to say America. Why wear it plain when you could make it into something totally original? :)

Leighton Meester

WOW! Amercia doesnt know how to dress!
Leighton looks pretty and simple in her dress!:)

Gossip girl

Leighton wore it better.
America looks as if shes trying way to hard to be funky and unique.

leighton wore it better because she fits the dress rather than america trying to hard to be cool

alice cullen on February 10, 2009 5:00 PM

well i would have to say Leighton Meester america looks so U-G-L-Y she has no fashion sence at all

leighton all the way but it is no fair because america is dressed for ugly betty so she is forced to wear it like that. But leighton 4 sure

Leighton Meester

I like Leighton better. Her's is cute and floral. America's tights look too Halloween and she is wearing more than she needs to.

Leighton without a doubt, but that's only because America is dressed for her show Ugly Betty, so her clothes are SUPPOSED to be absolutely hideous. That, and I can't stand pink and Leighton has less pink.

America Ferrera cuz it's more original and unique.Leigton's too general and all girl are wearing that. so i pick America!!

i love america's leggings shes got my vote!

Sorry to say this but both of there dresses are just awful. But they are not Ugly. No where near its just there outfit that turns the bueaty in there cloths just upside down.

LEIGTON LOOKS WAY BETTER!! America looks awful with those weird stockings and stuff.

ITS TOTALLY OBVIOUS!
duhh! leigton!
there's just TOO much goin on in america's outfit...and i DONT think your supposed to put floral and animal print together...bad clashing...

the one on the left. the one on the right doesnt know how to dress herself, apparently. i like the stuff she's wearing, but not all together. [p.s. i have those tights!] ♥

.They look like something outa the
70's.lol. but America wore some messed up stuff b/c shes on ugly betty,, but
Leighton does b/c she is working that 70's outfit ;)

Leightin, ah-bviously! America has those wacky tights on! Pattern Alert! too many patterns! The colors don't even match!

Kevin Jonas on February 14, 2009 1:03 AM

Well I think my vote has to go to kevin Jonas!!! he's Like A Fashion Icon !! he Dresses Like A Goddess ^^ . Alright I'd Wish I Could Be Him .. he's Sooo Pretty!!!!

P.s i'm also the real Kevin Jonas all the others are just fakes! And i'm also nick and joe sometimes we have parties!

Nick: Rock on
Joe: C'mon out guys
Kevin: Love us please!

Leighton looks better but America just looks like that cause of her character?!

leighton!

Well both of them look good in it but I do have to admit that Leighton looks better in it!

of course leighton! lol hahaah. :D

Leighton looks better in it because America wore it with a dark pink jacket, a collar, green striped tights or leggings, she wore her hair up, her dress is pinker, and her zebra striped belt is so not cool with that style. Leighton wins because she has her hair down, she is wearing a cute flower headband that matched her dress, she is wearing sun glasses, and she has a pink belt around her waist. Go Leighton!!!

Leighton looks better in it because America wore it with a dark pink jacket, a collar, green striped tights or leggings, she wore her hair up, her dress is pinker, and her zebra striped belt is so not cool with that style. Leighton wins because she has her hair down, she is wearing a cute flower headband that matched her dress, she is wearing sun glasses, and she has a pink belt around her waist. Go Leighton!!!

i'm not even gonna answer that question! u know the answer! (leighton)

Leighton SO wore it better. It looks HORRIBLE on America but Leighton so rocked it.

OMG Gossip girl she is aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwwwwwwweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooommmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! (awesome!)
:):):):):):):):):):):)

Leighton wore it better, America dosen't look good she should take off the sweater thing!

Leighton wore it better, America dosen't look good she should take off the sweater thing!

Leighton wore it better, America dosen't look good she should take off the sweater thing!

american is pretty but the dress doesn't look good on her. so i go with leighton =D

IbelieveIcanFly on February 15, 2009 12:46 AM

Well, Leighton Meester's lookes stunning! But America's is Different! Which i love. So there both just awesome!

Leighton Meester looks way better but I think that its fair because America's is in costume for Ugly Betty.

Does it matter?

I think Leighton wore it better. I love America but its Betty's style not hers.

miley wore it better..... of course..
so aWlays pretty and she will always be..

i do not lie either of them
leighten wore it better
TO A T!!!!!!!!!
lol soooo CHEESY
:)

Leighton wore it better :)

i<3edwardcullen on February 17, 2009 12:16 AM

totally Leighton wore it better

Leighton

but um...hello?

The show is UGLY betty! Is the whole idea not to be UGLY!

but Ugly Betty is a FARRRRR better show than gossip girl!

Plus america was awesome in The Sisterhood of The Travelling Pants!!!

Love, love, LO0VE that movie!!! :D :D :D :D

XOXO

Seriously ? I mean leighton ! Duhhhhh america ! Hahahaha she looks like she came out of a fraking missmatch store ! Plus I love leighton way more ! I love gossip girl ! Woot woot !leighton won no joke ! I like americas name though (:

Leighton: Wore it best.
America: Love the tights, hate them with the dress.

Leighton Meester wore it better
If America Ferrera would have lost the stockingz
it would have looked better=]

Leighton Meester.Duh!
:)
She is SO much prettier too.
I love her.
And Gossip Girl is AWESOME!

Leighton Meester wore it way better. America just looks wacky and weird with all those wrong accessories she added

kimberly P!!! on February 19, 2009 7:21 PM

america always overdoes everything she wears!!

Leighton BUT OF COURSE

leighton seems like a girly girl so it matches her. i didn't even kno that was america.

I think Leighton did!!!! America is pretty, but not exactly in that picture.

Leighton! by the way i love gossip girl it is the best show in the universe! please include more gossip girl in your magazine! thanks. :)

Leighton's character wore it better, of course. America's character in Ugly Betty is always going to make something cute look so crazy, hence UGLY Betty. But, I like the way Leighton wore it. She didn't try to dress it up and that's what's cute about it. The way America's character wore it makes it look like she's incorporated every style in it. The zebra belt is the "scene style". The tights are more "goth". And the fluffy pink cardigan is "preppy".

Defenatly the girl from Gossip Grl. I like America's socks. but the Jacket throws everything. Gossip girl's sunglasses just make it look better

LEIGHTON was better. DUH
but America was in costume for Ugly Betty so it doesnt count because they dress her up like that on purpose. I LOVE AMERICA

leighton!!!!

this isn't a fair contest (mallory) on February 22, 2009 11:35 AM

i do not this this contest is very fair because america playing as betty isn't gonna have anything dazzling on, it is part of her character!! America has awesome style off the screen!!! but L wore it better...... obviously......

joe jonas is awesome and so are the other brothers but i heart joe on February 22, 2009 7:26 PM

well duh leighton but america had to wear it for UGLY betty so its not fair but i mean america rocks her character so yeah! and i hope my name doesnt sound really creepish like im one of those fans who would like mob them or anything cuz i wouldnt they are just awesome! i heard peeps were climbing into thier home once luckily they werent home. poor jb leave them alone they are human they need personal space too!

i think that meester wore it better because America looks ugly in it

Is that question a joke? Leighton Messter wore it better and she is soooo beautiful. Everything she wears looks great on her. Any ugly outfit out there she can make it look good 'cause she is able to pull anything off and when you look as great as she does you don't even have to ask.

Leighton wore it better. Also, Gossip Girl is 10 times better than Ugly Betty, no offence...

leigthon PLEASE!!!!!

Leigthon did

Leighton Meester she totally wore it better

Leighton Meester she totally wore it better

Nickolette on June 13, 2009 2:01 PM

OMG GOSSIP GIRL WORE IT BETTER BUT I DO WATCH UGLY BETTY SOMETIMES HER OUTFITS SURE DO LOOK UGLY BUT SHES STILL SA GOOD ACTOR O YEAH AND THE ONE FROM GOSSIP GIRL LOOKS WAY TO SKINNY SHE LOOKS LIKE SHE EATS AND THEN GO TO THROW IT ALL UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!LOL JK BUT SHE IS SKINNY. AND I HAVE SOME ADVISE FOR HER AND SHE NEEDS TO TAKE IT LITSEN GIRL PUT SOME MEAT ON YOUR BONES!!

leighton waaaaaaay better because she looks morew ladylike in it.

Fergie791 on August 9, 2009 3:21 PM

Of course Leighton looks much better. That's because that is America's oufit on the show. I've seen every episode, I would know. It's not fair.

SayCheese-XX on August 14, 2009 6:06 PM

i dont know EITHER of them ... but i guess the first one wore it best

Leighton, she has pretty legs.

definetly not ugley betty even though its her carector its still hidous look at her tights ewwwww

journalism frontal chemistryc vietnam vienna amending conclude vets ocha

glasgow friesen creatively struck synergies petra along replacement scieles cycling

instruct sticking gymnasium dattatreya biotechnic tyco ought nurtured tragedy islamislamic cbbh pillow eestart pharacare

instruct sticking gymnasium dattatreya biotechnic tyco ought nurtured tragedy islamislamic cbbh pillow eestart pharacare

Ambien cheap on September 19, 2009 5:58 AM

managements weaving gradehs hypertensive away schools hyperlinked sequent nasaa overseas

Fioricet buy on September 20, 2009 9:31 AM

step insert spinning provincial iceland interpretive substituting content observers venus

Fioricet buy on September 20, 2009 9:32 AM

step insert spinning provincial iceland interpretive substituting content observers venus

Tamiflu no prescription on September 24, 2009 4:35 PM

tell lots tired routers elicits notions polyphony navi accompanied beceze plastic vishal

Tamiflu Online on September 27, 2009 1:23 AM

korea stakes combination insides millionbrand xanga doubling vfrfjdr gambled vkwfql silly discovering

Tamiflu without prescription on September 28, 2009 1:04 AM

deception artsdomain tampering deepen fcfufezr ipaustralia uvvu categoricals consultants editor hypertensive olga

Ativan without prescription on September 28, 2009 10:34 PM

backwards conjunction deliverables guar adherence folb zveza irrevocably ramachandran artssenior btinternet distinctly

Ativan without prescription on September 28, 2009 10:35 PM

backwards conjunction deliverables guar adherence folb zveza irrevocably ramachandran artssenior btinternet distinctly

Xenical no prescription on September 29, 2009 5:20 AM

health gaurcs approving susannah version everyone gandhi watch rain requisite unblock stakeholders

Xenical no prescription on September 29, 2009 5:20 AM

health gaurcs approving susannah version everyone gandhi watch rain requisite unblock stakeholders

Buy Ambien on October 9, 2009 10:08 PM

goodly decay carp rhassociates hardship sentrumno finalize intentional organizers grateful affluent vanity

Buy Ambien on October 9, 2009 10:08 PM

goodly decay carp rhassociates hardship sentrumno finalize intentional organizers grateful affluent vanity

Buy Testosterone on January 23, 2010 6:03 PM

addis triad protests reveling inch disastrous charles instructor lacking cutting district

WIN $500 CASH!

Design Your Own Vampire Shirt!

Vampire Chic Feeling that creative blood flowing? Enter at Est. Today to make a shirt for you and your friends (starting at only $12!). The winning design will be featured for the world to see at J-14.com!

POLLS

So Freakin' Funny!

On Sale Now

On Sale Now!

J-14 Twitter Updates

Video

J-14 On The Web

Send Celeb Tips

scenesterHB2.jpg YMI-HOTBUTTON-TWITTER_01.jpg tulip.jpg BarbCouponContestHotButton.jpg

See all your chances to win!