No WayDiscover 12 Totally Unlikely Couples You Won’t Believe Ever Dated

6 of 12

Lucy Hale and David Henrie

Pretty Little Liars' Lucy Hale dated Wizards of Waverly Place star David Henrie for a couple years before calling it quits for good. It definitely didn't end well, but it seems like they're finally getting along again!

Credit: Twitter
Tinashe Hot Pics