'The Summer I Turned Pretty' Belly and Jeremiah's Relationship Timeline

The Summer I Turned Pretty‘s premiered on Amazon Prime in June 2022, and it’s safe to say that the series was a hit. So many fans are already choosing teams between Belly’s love interests, brothers Jeremiah and Conrad. Keep reading to see Belly and Jeremiah’s complete relationship timeline throughout the show! Warning: Spoilers ahead.

TSITP follows the love triangle between a girl named Belly (Lola Tung) and her two childhood best friends, brothers Conrad (Christopher Briney) and Jeremiah (Gavin Casalegno). The show is based on a book series by Jenny Han, who is also the author of To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before, which had its own successful adaptation on Netflix.

“It’s all the thrill and excitement of first love and what it’s like to really love someone from afar your whole life and then suddenly be interacting with them in a new way,” Han told Entertainment Weekly in April 2022. “We’ll see the night swims and big crushes and all those sort of big, epic love moments this season. I did try to drop in a lot of Easter eggs throughout the series for the fans of the books.”

Ahead of the show‘s premiere, the actors opened up about their thoughts adapting the book’s characters into their own. The actors told J-14 that they worked hard to bring “authenticity” to the love triangle.

“Worrying about what other people are gonna think — even in real life — worrying about what other people are gonna think is going to stress you out and make you worry about the little things,” Gavin said of the pressure to bring the adaptation to life. “I think with our relationship, and with our romantic relationship with Belly, it was so much fun just being able to explore the authenticity of it and the genuineness … just it being so genuine. It was so much fun to work with Lola on screen. I felt like everything just kind of went super smoothly. I know everyone’s gonna love it.”

And is Gavin Team Jeremiah or Team Conrad? “I have to be Team Jeremiah,” the actor — who stars as Jeremiah — shares. “I will say, love Team Cam Cameron (David Iacono). That’s that’s all I’ll say about that.”

Scroll to see Belly and Jeremiah’s relationship timeline throughout the first season of TSITP.

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.

First Meeting

In episode 1, Belly finally arrives at the Fisher brother’s summer home — looking very pretty, might we add. Jeremiah gives her a huge hug and warm welcome, even though she was mostly excited to see Conrad, her childhood crush. After her arrival, Jeremiah convinced Belly to swim with him at the beach and they have a cute splashing-each-other-in-the-water-montage-moment.

Later that night, Jeremiah and Belly sneak out for a bonfire party which ends up going terribly wrong. It’s not all bad though, because Belly meets and immediately hit it off with a guy named Cam, and they kiss.

Team Jeremiah Prevails

After an awkward partner switch up at a volleyball tournament which we won’t get into in episode 6, Jeremiah and Belly seem to still be going strong!

Belly and Taylor are left stranded without clothes after being dared to skinny dip (long story), and Conrad and Jeremiah drive separately to pick them up. Belly chooses Jeremiah to drive her home and asks him to be her date at the debutante ball and the two make out.

Later that night, Belly told Conrad that it was “too late.”

Last Dance

In the beginning of the final episode, Conrad told Belly that Jeremiah was the right choice for her, which she responded, “I know.”

At the debutante ball, Jeremiah finds out that his mom Susannah’s cancer has returned, and Conrad has known the entire summer without telling him. Stunned by this information, he is nowhere to be found during the rehearsed dance, leaving Belly stranded. Conrad swoops in, and Belly and Conrad share a romantic dance until Jeremiah storms in and punches Conrad in the face. Yikes.

At the very end of the episode, Conrad and Belly kiss on the beach, leading audiences to assume that she chooses Conrad.

That’s all until next season, folks!

Road Trip!

Jeremiah is justifiably angry with Belly in the beginning of season 2: due to her, you know, ending things with him to begin a relationship with Conrad. However, Conrad and Belly’s relationship fizzles out by the time season 2 kicks off.

After Jeremiah can’t reach his older brother, he and Belly take a road trip to Cousins Beach to find him.

End of Season 2

Belly starts to develop more feelings for Jeremiah during their Cousins Beach trip and he forgives her for their past history.

During a trip to Brown University with Conrad, the duo share a passionate kiss that begins their budding romance.

Of course, nothing can happen until Belly talks with Conrad — so that’s what she does. Following their conversation, in which he seemingly lies about his feelings, Belly decides to try things out with Jeremiah. The season ends with them together.