Happy birthday, Ashley Benson! The Pretty Little Liars actress turns 25 years old today, and we're celebrating her big day (and Throwback Thursday) by a taking a look at her pre-Hanna Marin acting gigs.

From ABC Family movies to cancelled TV shows — and even a costarring role with Kevin McHale — click through to see roles you probably forgot she starred in. Let us know which one shocked you the most in the comments!