When we talked to Madison Pettis last summer, she casually mentioned the guy she was dating — but we didn't know his identity. So who's the dude? She posted a photo with Garrett Backstrom that's definitely raising eyebrows, especially because she previously told J-14 that she's given her boyfriend NFL gifts before. (And what are the Late Bloomer co-stars wearing in the photo? Football apparel.)

"I’ve bought gifts for like my boyfriend on NFL before and then bought stuff for myself too so they’re really cute for watching games but also not even when you’re just watching games," she told us last summer.

However, it looks like he's been dating another girl. His girlfriend Mary posted a photo just two months ago, showing that they're definitely in a relationship.

While they could have broken up since then, this means that the guy Madison told us about definitely isn't Garrett. Basically, this is all very confusing. Garrett and Madison could be dating, but it's more likely she has a different boyfriend and they're merely co-stars hanging out.

MORE: 'CORY IN THE HOUSE': WHERE ARE THEY NOW?

Click through to see more photos of them together, and let us know if you think they're cute in the comments!

Reporting credit: Kristine Hope Kowalski and Jennifer Maldonado