Since their rise to fame back in 2016, fans have wondered whether or not the Why Don’t We boys were single. Throughout their time in the spotlight, Zach HerronDaniel SeaveyJack Avery, Corbyn Besson and Jonah Marais have kept their relationship status pretty much under wraps, but that hasn’t stopped their biggest fans from spilling all the tea about their love lives online. From one time flings to longterm girlfriends and everything in between, it’s finally time to break down each and every relationship these heartthrobs have ever had.

From YouTube stars to their high school sweethearts and some others in between, this five-piece boyband has known to leave fans guessing about relationship status (but sometimes posts some seriously adorable photos) on social media. But what exactly went down with Why Don’t We and their significant others? Why did they break up with their former girlfriends? Who is still in a relationship? No worries, guys, because J-14 has you covered! We broke down all their relationships from start to finish.

Scroll through our gallery to uncover the complete history of everyone Why Don’t We has ever dated and what went down between them.

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.