Ever since she got catapulted into fame through her leading role in Pretty Little Liars, Ashley Benson‘s love life has been in the spotlight. The actress has been linked to a ton of guys and girls over the years (including Justin Bieber‘s stylist, one of her PLL costars and an actor from Glee!), and sometimes, it’s a little hard to keep up.

Most recently, the blonde beauty was linked to model Cara Delevingne. Rumors first started swirling that the two were dating after they were spotted packing on the PDA back in May 2018. After that, they quickly became couple goals — constantly sharing the cutest pics on Instagram, gushing over each other and supporting each other’s work.

But fans were left heartbroken when news hit the web that they had decided to go their separate ways on May 6, 2020.

That’s right, after more than two years together, In Touch confirmed that the actress and model have officially broken up, and fans are pretty heartbroken over the news.

“This split is not surprising to Ashely and Cara’s inner circle,” a source told Life & Style. “The thing is that no one wanted it to be true. They were great together, a dynamic duo and everyone loved having them around. That’s why this is so hard.”

The insider also explained that the pair started to “grow apart” and said they “know it wasn’t an easy decision” for the couple to ultimately split.

But wait, who did Ashley date before Cara? Let’s take walk down memory lane. There sure is a lot to unpack, and lucky for you, we’ve got the ultimate breakdown. Scroll through the gallery to uncover everyone Ashley has ever dated and what went down between them.

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.