It looks like Noah Centineo may have had some casting dreams for the To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before sequel that didn’t come true. Yep, that’s right, the heartthrob recently joked that he wished Riverdale star Cole Sprouse had a role in the Netflix rom-com, and fans are so here for it!

On Tuesday, March 3, the 23-year-old took to his Instagram Stories and showed his 18.7 million followers a framed photo of the To All The Boys 2: P.S. I Still Love You cast hanging on a wall. Noah and Lana Condor were both in the image, but instead of Jordan Fisher — who played John Ambrose in the film — the third actor pictured was Cole. Wait, what?! As fans know, The Suite Life of Zack and Cody alum didn’t have a role in the newly released movie.

Naturally, Noah made a total joke out of the entire situation.

“Yo, I’m confused. So when did Cole Sprouse join our cast?” he asked, showing fans the photo and tagging the fellow actor.

Noah Centineo Wishes Cole Sprouse Joined The ‘To All The Boys 2’ Cast

In a separate video, Noah revealed that having Cole as a part of the TATBILB film franchise would have been “fantastic.”

“I’m actually upset because that would have been a fantastic movie,” he admitted.

Noah Centineo Wishes Cole Sprouse Joined The ‘To All The Boys 2’ Cast

Then, in typical Noah fashion, he totally trolled To All The Boys I’ve Loved Before producer Aubrey Bendix.

“Aubrey, why wasn’t Cole in the movie with us?” he asked. To which she replied, “Um….”

It was unclear to viewers exactly where Noah and Aubrey were when he discovered the frame photo, but some fans have speculated that he was working on something that had to with the third To All The Boys film. For those who don’t know, the final film in the the trilogy is set to hit Netflix soon, and according to the film’s stars, there might be trouble in paradise for fan-favorite couple Lara Jean Covey and Peter Kavinsky when it’s finally released.

“The third movie really explores what happens when you’re in a relationship and then you have all the real-life stuff that comes into play,” the author of the book series that inspired the romantic comedies, Jenny Han, told Entertainment Tonight. “If I’m doing my job right, you’re worried.”

Uh oh, looks like fans have a lot to look forward to!

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.