By now, it’s safe to say Noah Centineo has stolen hearts everywhere and in case you were wondering if any of the hype around the internet’s boyfriend has died down, well think again. It’s still going strong and when he took to Instagram to share a photo of him and his “girlfriend,” everyone lost their minds over it. And it’s honestly amazing.

So here’s what went down: the 22-year-old To All the Boys I’ve Loved Before star attended Universal’s Hollywood Horror Nights and shared a festive pic from the evening where’s face-to-face with a rather spooky werewolf who wasn’t exactly happy to see him. “My girlfriend and I had a fight last night,” he wrote in the caption of the pic he posted on Instagram.

Noah Centineo
Universal Horror Nights

And that’s when Noah’s comments sections were flooded with even other celebs chiming in about how they think of themselves as his girlfriend and this isn’t their most flattering photo. LOL! Stars really are just like the rest of us. Kiernan Shipka, aka our new Sabrina Spellman who has once casually proposed to Noah on Instagram, wrote “That’s not me though!” And we’re like same girl, same.

Kiernan Noah Instagram Comment

YouTubers James Charles and Tana Mongeau left similar comments too, with James writing, “Omg babe delete this it’s not a good pic of me” and Tana going with “great pic of us babe” along with some heart-eye emojis.

Noah Instagram Comments

Literally the same type of comments we all leave on Noah’s pics if we’re being honest here. But alas, as far as we know, the actor is still very much single, as he’s super busy being a superstar at the moment, currently filming the upcoming Charlie’s Angels movie. Although, he did seem to find someone to marry, or so he says. Noah took to Instagram to share another Halloween pic that slayed hearts where he’s holding none other than Ross Butler, as they’re dressed as Gaston and Wolverine, respectively. “Everyone’s invited to the wedding,” Noah wrote in the caption.

Ross Butler Noah Centineo
Getty Images

Now this one ship we have a feeling fans will totally get behind.

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.