Despite the fact that they kept their whirlwind romance under wraps, fans were still obsessed with Hailee Steinfeld and Niall Horan‘s past relationship.

The pair first met in 2017 after performing on the Jingle Ball Tour together, but romance rumors didn’t start swirling until January 2018. When the Pitch Perfect star was asked about the nature of her relationship with Niall during an interview with Us Weekly, she declined to divulge any details.

“I feel so lucky that [my fans] care enough about me to know what I’m doing every second of every day, but I think that sometimes it’s hard for people in general to realize that there are boundaries to a person’s life and personal life,” Hailee said at the time.

After a little over a year together, the two went their separate ways. Following their short-lived love story, the pair wrote a few songs about each other and Hailee seemingly shaded the One Direction member multiple times. Now, J-14 has decided to take a walk down memory lane and break down Niall and Hailee’s relationship from start to finish, including the drama that followed. Scroll through our gallery for a complete timeline.

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.