This may be hard to believe, but some of your favorite actors have starred in multiple iconic roles over the years. Yep, although we’re so used to seeing Shay Mitchell as Emily Fields in Pretty Little Liars, for example, she’s actually gone on to appear in other pretty notable roles, too.

So, we decided to round up a few stars like Dylan Minnette, Austin Butler, Jenna Ortega, Sasha Pieterse, Finn Wolfhard, Penn Badgley, Kat Graham, Taylor Lautner, Noah Centineo, Debby Ryan, Emily Osment and more to show you the memorable characters they played in the past that you might not remember. So, prepare to be shook over because your mind is about to be blown. These actors and actresses can seriously play any type of role and this seriously proved it!

Scroll through the gallery to uncover all the characters you had no idea were played by the same actor.

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.