We can all agree that Cole Sprouse and Lili Reinhart made one of the cutest couples ever — that is, until news broke that the pair reportedly called it quits after nearly two years together. But what led to their ultimate split? How did they start dating in the first place? Let’s take a walk down memory lane, shall we?

In case you forgot, the duo met and fell for each other on set of Riverdale, and we were all seriously living for their adorable relationship. Their characters are pretty much goals in the CW series, so when they took their romance off screen and revealed that they were dating IRL, we all quickly became obsessed with them. While they always kept their love life pretty private over the years, they did post adorable photos together and gush over each other in interviews from time to time.

But when exactly did they become more than friends, you ask? And how did they realize they had feelings for each other? Well guys, we’re breaking it down for you from start to finish. It’s actually been quite a long and complicated journey for the former lovebirds. We went ahead and made you a complete guide to their romance, so scroll through our gallery to uncover Cole and Lili’s complete relationship timeline.

Love J-14? Be sure to subscribe to our YouTube channel for fun, exclusive videos with your favorite stars.